Worst Carnival Cruise Ships to Avoid can turn your cruise vacation from exciting to disappointing. While some vessels shine with great food, friendly service, and fun activities, others leave guests frustrated with overcrowding, outdated features, or poor service.

This guide highlights real stories and reviews from travelers to help you avoid the worst Carnival cruise ships. From mixed feedback on newer ships to complaints about older ones, knowing what to expect can save you time, money, and stress.

“A cruise should leave you with memories of joy, not moments of regret.”

By learning from past guest experiences, you can choose the right ship for your needs and enjoy a smoother journey at sea.

Worst Carnival Cruise Ships to Avoid

Here is a list of the worst Carnival cruise ships:

1. Carnival Luminosa Cruise
2. Carnival Sunshine Cruise
3. Carnival Venezia Cruise
4. Carnival Radiance Cruise
5. Carnival Paradise Cruise
6. Carnival Elation Cruise
7. Carnival Splendor Cruise
8. Carnival Horizon Cruise
9. Carnival Liberty Cruise
10. Carnival Spirit Cruise
11. Carnival Legend Cruise
12. Carnival Conquest Cruise
13. Carnival Mardi Gras Cruise
14. Carnival Freedom Cruise
15. Carnival Magic Cruise

1: Carnival Luminosa Cruise in Alaska

Carnival Luminosa may offer scenic views of Alaska, its overall experience leaves much to be desired. Despite its renovations and previous stint in Australia, many passengers find its offerings lack the excitement and luxury expected from a Carnival ship. The limited variety of activities and outdated amenities make the ship feel underwhelming compared to others in the fleet.

“Not every cruise is a dream vacation; some fall short of expectations, leaving passengers with more frustration than fun.”

The Carnival Luminosa lack of engaging entertainment options and the cramped feel of the ship leave many travelers disappointed. With few dining choices and outdated facilities, Carnival Luminosa struggles to provide the level of comfort and luxury many expect. While the views of glaciers are stunning, they are not enough to make up for the ship’s shortcomings in terms of overall experience. For those seeking a more vibrant and enjoyable cruise, Carnival Luminosa may not be the best choice.

2: Carnival Sunshine Cruise

The Carnival Sunshine has received mixed reviews from passengers, with many highlighting its outdated facilities and lack of modern amenities. While some may appreciate its colorful decor and lively entertainment, the ship’s aging infrastructure and inconsistent service often lead to a less-than-ideal experience.

Carnival Sunshine sails between praise and problems—where bright fun meets faded charm.

The cabins of Carnival Cruise are cramped, and the dining options feel limited, especially compared to newer ships in the Carnival fleet. This duality affects its reputation at sea, with reviews mixed on its tight spaces and dated design.

3: Carnival Venezia Cruise

While the Carnival Venezia may attract guests with its stylish decor and promises of fun activities, many reviews point out its shortcomings, making it one of the worst choices for a Carnival cruise. Despite exciting entertainment and dining options, passengers often report overcrowding, long waits, and inconsistent service quality, leading to a frustrating experience.

The cabins of Carnival Venezia adapted from a European design, are often described as smaller or poorly arranged, which may leave some guests feeling cramped. Although there are kid-friendly features like water parks and clubs, they are fewer compared to those on larger ships. Departures from New York attract a mix of families and adults, but the overall atmosphere may feel festive, yet far from the high expectations set by the ship’s promotional material.

The conversion from Costa may explain some of these issues, and reading up on its renovation details can help manage expectations. Ultimately, this growing trend in guest feedback highlights that the Carnival Venezia may not meet the needs of travelers seeking a truly enjoyable cruise experience.

4: Carnival Radiance Cruise

Carnival Radiance, formerly known as Carnival Victory, may have undergone major refurbishments, but many passengers still find it lacking compared to newer ships in the Carnival fleet, making it one of the worst choices for some cruisers. Despite upgrades in amenities, vibrant decor, and better dining options, many passengers report that the overall experience falls short of expectations.

Renovations might have given it a fresh coat of paint, but the Carnival Radiance still feels stuck in the past, failing to meet modern cruise expectations.

While some cruisers enjoy the lively entertainment and exciting waterslides, the service remains inconsistent, and minor issues persist. When compared to larger, more modern vessels like Mardi Gras or Reflection, Carnival Radiance feels outdated, leaving some guests disappointed with the mixed experience.

5: Carnival Paradise Cruise

The Carnival Paradise continues to disappoint many passengers, often criticized for its outdated design and lack of modern amenities. The ship’s classic decor may appeal to a few, but the absence of high-tech features makes it feel stuck in the past. Compared to newer ships, it lacks the luxury and convenience travelers expect.

“While Carnival Paradise tries to capture a nostalgic vibe, it falls short, leaving many passengers wishing for more modern comforts and services.”

The ship’s small size results in overcrowding, and the facilities feel cramped and outdated. Dining options are limited, and the entertainment is underwhelming, offering little to keep passengers engaged. Its outdated infrastructure and lack of technological updates make Carnival Paradise one of the least appealing ships in the Carnival fleet.

6: Carnival Elation Cruise

Carnival Elation often disappoints passengers with its outdated design and lack of modern amenities. Despite its attempt to offer a nostalgic, old-school cruising experience, many find its small size and aging decor less than appealing.

The compact size leads to overcrowding, making the experience less enjoyable compared to newer ships. Long waits at restaurants and bars are common, which dampens the otherwise personal experience. The lack of high-tech amenities and modern features leaves the ship feeling stuck in the past, and it often falls short when compared to newer vessels in the Carnival fleet.

Despite some passengers appreciating its charm, Carnival Elation fails to impress those looking for a more polished, comfortable, and up-to-date cruise experience.

7: Carnival Splendor Cruise

Carnival Splendor often leaves passengers with a disappointing cruising experience, marked by overcrowding, service inconsistencies, and operational hiccups. While the vibrant decor and family-friendly amenities may appeal to some, the ship falls short in key areas, making it one of the worst choices for cruisers seeking a smooth and enjoyable vacation.

“Carnival Splendor might look bright and fun on the outside, but its crowded spaces and frequent service delays make it more stressful than enjoyable for many passengers.”

The long wait times at dining venues and inconsistent service are common complaints, with many passengers feeling frustrated by the lack of efficiency. The ship’s tendency to get overcrowded, especially in public spaces, takes away from the relaxation many expect during their cruise. While the entertainment options are plentiful, the overall experience often feels more hectic than relaxing, leaving many guests questioning whether it’s worth the hassle.

8: Carnival Horizon Cruise

While the Carnival Horizon may seem modern compared to other ships in the fleet, many passengers find it lacking in several key areas, making it one of the worst Carnival cruises for some travelers. The ship’s size and popularity lead to overcrowding, making it difficult to enjoy the amenities without long wait times and a sense of chaos.

“While it promises excitement, the Carnival Horizon often feels more like a crowded theme park than a relaxing vacation.”

Although the WaterWorks water park and Serenity Deck offer some appeal, the ship’s layout and crowded areas leave many passengers feeling overwhelmed. The lack of personal space and frequent service delays at dining venues result in a less-than-relaxing experience. While the SkyRide and themed restaurants may seem exciting, the overall atmosphere of the ship can often feel more stressful than enjoyable, especially during peak times.

9: Carnival Liberty Cruise

Despite its promising destinations, Carnival Liberty leaves much to be desired for passengers seeking a relaxing, modern cruise experience. While it connects travelers to vibrant Caribbean destinations, many find the ship outdated, with less-than-impressive amenities compared to newer Carnival vessels.

“Carnival Liberty might sail to beautiful places, but the ship itself falls flat with its outdated facilities and frequent service delays.”

The Carnival Liberty aging design results in cramped spaces and a lack of modern features, making it feel less luxurious than other options in the fleet. Dining experiences are often inconsistent, with long waits at restaurants and crowded buffets, leaving many guests frustrated. While the entertainment is adequate, it doesn’t live up to the expectations set by newer ships, and the overall experience can feel underwhelming. For those looking for a more polished, relaxing cruise, Carnival Liberty may not be the best choice.

10: Carnival Spirit Cruise

The Carnival Spirit often disappoints passengers with its outdated features and operational inefficiencies. Despite offering an array of entertainment options and scenic itineraries, the ship’s aging design and crowded spaces make it a frustrating experience for many. The lack of modern amenities compared to newer ships makes it feel stuck in the past.

“Carnival Spirit may promise scenic exploration, but overcrowding, inconsistent service, and outdated facilities leave many passengers wishing for more.”

Although the ship is known for smooth navigation and unique ports of call, the frequent complaints about long wait times at dining venues and crowded public spaces overshadow these positives. The ship’s ability to attract a more mature crowd doesn’t compensate for its lack of luxury and modern features

11: Carnival Legend Cruise 

The Carnival Legend may boast a mid-size design and claims of offering a more personal and relaxed atmosphere, but it often falls short when it comes to delivering a smooth, enjoyable experience. While its design aims for sophistication, many guests find it outdated, lacking the modern amenities and excitement offered by newer, larger ships in the fleet.

“Despite its attempts at creating a peaceful ambiance, Carnival Legend often feels underwhelming with its limited attractions, outdated design, and lack of engaging features.”

Although the itineraries may include scenic routes, the overall experience feels stagnant compared to the more vibrant, modern cruise options available today. For those seeking a luxurious, lively cruise, Carnival Legend fails to meet the mark, often leaving passengers disappointed.

12: Carnival Conquest Cruise

The Carnival Conquest may have space for over 3,500 guests, but many passengers find its size more of a burden than a benefit. The ship’s aging infrastructure and overcrowded spaces often lead to a cramped, uncomfortable experience, with many areas feeling congested and lacking the comfort and luxury found on newer ships.

“Despite its size, Carnival Conquest fails to impress, offering outdated amenities, poor service, and long waits that diminish the vacation experience.”

While Carnival Conquest may attract budget-conscious first-time cruisers, the lack of modern upgrades and quality dining options make it feel far behind the times. The food quality and limited variety are frequent points of dissatisfaction, especially when compared to newer ships in the fleet. Carnival Conquest struggles to meet expectations for a relaxing, enjoyable cruise, leaving many passengers wishing they had chosen a more modern vessel.

13: Carnival Mardi Gras Cruise

Carnival Mardi Gras promises a lively celebration, but many passengers find the ship underwhelming and overcrowded. Despite its festive atmosphere, the ship often feels cramped, with limited spaces for relaxation, especially during peak times. The lack of modern amenities and crowded public areas take away from the excitement that the ship initially promises.

“The celebration can quickly turn into frustration as long lines, inconsistent service, and overcrowded spaces dominate the experience.”

While Carnival Mardi Gras may attract travelers seeking a festive cruise, the chaotic environment, long wait times, and lack of personal space make it less enjoyable for those seeking comfort and ease. Carnival Mardi Gras may deliver in terms of party atmosphere, but it falls short in providing a relaxing, luxurious cruise experience.

14: Carnival Freedom Cruise

While Carnival Freedom offers a range of dining options and lively entertainment, it often falls short in delivering a satisfying cruise experience. The ship’s layout is one of the main complaints, with overcrowding and poorly designed spaces detracting from the relaxed atmosphere many expect. The cramped feel in public areas makes it difficult to enjoy the amenities without feeling rushed or uncomfortable.

Though the entertainment, including themed shows and talented performers, is praised by some, the ship’s operational inefficiencies and inconsistent service quality often lead to a frustrating experience. Despite its modern amenities, the lack of smooth service and uncomfortable layout make it one of the worst choices for those looking for a seamless and enjoyable cruise.

15: Carnival Magic Cruise

Carnival Magic suffers from overcrowding, making many common areas feel cramped and uncomfortable. Passengers often complain about long wait times at dining venues and the lack of available seating in popular spots. Despite its size, the ship feels chaotic, especially during peak times, leaving little room for relaxation.

The water park, though popular with kids, adds to the noise and congestion, further diminishing the overall experience. Service quality is inconsistent, with many guests reporting delays and frustration with staff members, which only compounds the ship’s operational inefficiencies. The ship’s design, intended to offer adventure, often ends up feeling more crowded than fun, and the lack of modern amenities makes it fall short of newer Carnival vessels.

Carnival Magic fails to provide the comfort, luxury, or smooth service expected from a premium cruise, making it one of the worst options for travelers seeking a relaxing vacation at sea.

Conclusion

Frequently Asked Questions